We always knew that Purple Man killed five children but we were never entirely sure how he did so. Well today, we have FNAF S, and this new game gives us those answers.
I must address this first before I start. In one of the ending we see a set of five tombstones and one in the distance. These five tombstone could be the names of the five dead children, with the tombstone in the distance being the male crying child, however two them are the name's of the protagonists from FNAF 2. This measn that these names could actually be the names of the protagonists from the games, with Michael being one of the names we can't see.
I'd like to say these are the definite names of the children but it's just as likely they are the names of long dead secuirty guards so I can't say for sure.Anyways on with what this is really about.
The Last Two Children.
In the first game is when we hear about the missing children's incite but there's something about it is very particular:
"Two local childen were reportedly lured into a backroom during the late operation at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza..."
"Five Children are now linked to the incident at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza."
This implies that the two children were taken on one night but the other three, well it doesn't say. The implication is that they were taken on seperate occasions but their kidnappings were only linked after the two children were taken during this incident.
The Runaway
In the Midnight Motorist minigame we are shown a presumedly alcholic abusive father trying to get into his son's room only to find that he broke out the window with small footprints trailing off with a pair of larger more animatronic like footprints next to it.
The father remarks that his son ran off to "that place" again, believing his son to have break out of his room and left.
What I believe happened is this: His son likes to go to "that place" that place being a family friendly pizzeria, probably the only place he could get away from his abusive dad. This is where Afton took noticed of him. He went to his house and lured him out using the springbonnie costume to seem friendly. That's why you can see footprints from an animatronic there, and why you can see small footprints walking away; the boy came willingly.
In one part of the minigame you can see a lump in the ground. This is where I presume he buried little orange after killing him. Of course, there is a liklihood he stuffed him in an animtronic but Casette Man implies that stuffing them in animatronics came later, so it's possible at this point he just hide the bodies where ever.
Poor Doggy
In the Fruit Maze minigame you can see a reflection of a smiling little girl every so now again playing the game. After beating the game the first time the game distorts, and the second time distorting even more. The girl becomes sad and springbonnie appears behind her. Images of a dead dog appear on the spring and when the time runs out on the third game the words:
"He's not really dead... He is over here. Follow me..."
As many have surmized this little girl saw her dog die, the images from the game suggest it got run over. Willaim in the suit tells the girl that he's not really dead in order to lure her away to kill her.
Despite her also having blonde hair like Elisabeht we know she's a different child as her eye colour is blue, not green.
The Puppet
The Puppet child is sometimes thought to be the earliest children to be killed but I believe she one of the later children, I'll explain.
We are told finally her story to the best of the detail throught the puppet minigame and through Casette Man's dialogue. In the minigame, as the puppet, we're suppose to stop the child with the green band from leaving the restaurant but that child doesn't show up. That is until one game where she's already outside the restaurant with the children inside seeming to laugh at her, the puppet trapped in his box. The puppet frees itself and tries to find her but it is too late.
In one of the endings there are some secret blueprints about Lefty, explaining he was created to capture children, but there is some very percular text in it:
"B: False Sensory Output
NOTES: Bracelet code 93401233. Emit for security receiver frequency FZ554."
This implies there are bracelets that emit frequencies that the company created. It's likely Casette Man (or Henry I should call him, since these files do have his name on them) gave a bracelet to his daughter. The Puppet would then be programmed to keep who ever wears that bracelet inside the restuarant and out of danger, thus giving his daughter perfect protection. Unforunately, children always ruin the lives of children and a few brats trapped her outside and the puppet in his box leaving her vunerable to Purple Man's clutches.
This left Henry devestated and left him to looking to avenge his daughter.
Timeline
As I said, the Puppet child wasn't the first killing since it happened after William had developed Lefty. It wasn't the last either as I explained by the newspapers from 1, two children being abducted were the catalyst that stopped it.
Henry's daughter's death I believe took place sometime shortly before they moved from the old location to the new one as mentioned in FNAF 2. He see in TCTTC that Freddy exists in this restaurant so it can't be as old as Fredbear's Dinner as they probably wouldn't have created him at that point, and it doesn't look like toy Freddy so it can't be later on. This restaurant also has a puppet which we know they had before they moved to the new location as we see it in the opening cutscenes in 2.
This would also explain why Phone Guy says things like:
"Uh, now, I want you to forget anything you may have heard about the old location, you know. Uh, some people still have a somewhat negative impression of the company."'
"Oh, hey, before I go, uh, I wanted to ease your mind about any rumors you might have heard lately. You know how these local stories come and go and seldom mean anything. I can personally assure you that, whatever is going on out there, and however tragic it may be, has nothing to do with our establishment."
And that would all be sort of true. Is something happened outside the restaurant it may be easy for them to pass it off like nothing happened at all.
The two children that went missing probably took place after this since phone guy talks about "t'here's been somewhat of an, uh, investigation going on.'" And we know an investigation is what exactly happened after those two kids went missing.
Orange Boy and Puppy Girl (I'm calling them that until we get a more offical name) it's hard to get a firm date down and when those two incidents happened. I believe they both happened before Elisabeth but the when and where gets a bit Murky.
We know something bad happened at Fredbear's Family Diner because Phone Guy mentions contacting the original store owners, and I think that's because of the investigation going that had police looking into any other kidnapping incidents that relate back to the Fazbear franchise.
I think Orange Boy probably like going to Fredbear Family Diner, and was killed while it was open. We see Puppy Girl playing the arcade game in th minigame, which suggests she likes playibf arcade games which would place her death in 80's around the time that FFP was around, as we know Fredbear's had been close "for years". Through process of elimination that make Orange Boy the one killed at FFD
tl;dr
1st death - Orange Boy
2nd death - Puppy Girl
3rd death - Puppet Child
4th and 5th death - Remaining two children.
Okay, so that's my theory. Let me know what you think.