FANDOM


  • Merebry
    Merebry closed this thread because:
    Damn, there sure is a lot of necroposting lately
    21:00, January 2, 2018

    Treesicle explained sometime ago that William Afton (The Purple Guy) is actually innocent, and that his friend Henry is the real murderer. I believe that theory, or "true fact" 100%, but I'm not sure if it's even a theory. But here are ten good reason why I believe Henry is the true antagonist of the Five Nights universe:

    1. He is a mastermind and has a big skill on framing.
    2. He created the animatronics in order to frame William for the murders.
    3. I see him as a traitor, corrupting influence, and a Complete Monster.
    4. He can be nicknamed as "The Menace", "The Uncorruptable" or "The Smart One".
    5. I often think of him as a heartless threat to many innocent children.
    6. If he's ever revealed to be an evil mastermind of such potential power, then authorities would not only arrest him, but give him the electric where he will be dead once and for all.
    7. It should have been Henry to be killed by those poor, restless children. Not William.
    8. In my opinion, Fredbear is programmed to be a good-hearted animatronic to every kid. That leads to Henry becoming evil, because his programming plan of making him a killing machine fails.
    9. He's not only a murderous mastermind, but also a very strict gambler who wins a thousand dollars every five nights.
    10. In conclusion, Henry's overall plan is this: Create a diversion to make animatronics as a distraction of William Afton in order to shutdown Fazbear Entertainment after winning 50,000 dollars from a current gamble. Before shutting down the company, he'll kill every kid that goes to the restaurants and stuff them in suits. When he does shut down the company after killing the kids, he'll become the tyrant of Fazbear Entertainment and rule the company all to himself.

    So, what do you fellows believe? Am I making sense, or is this just a big old bag of nonsense?

    Leave your thoughts below.

      Loading editor
    • Umm...

      Who's Henry?

        Loading editor
    • Green Creeper wrote: Umm...

      Who's Henry?

      I think a silver eyes character. Co founder of Freddy Fazbear's pizza in the boom I think

        Loading editor
    • Nah, the novel lead you to believe Henry was also a villain but it's quickly debunked as Charlie remembers the kind of man Henry was. Having said that http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2287447 I do think in the games Henry ends up as Purple Guy and not William Afton.

        Loading editor
    • But the book has a separate universe to the FNAF lore.

        Loading editor
    • Excuse me bt thats wrong.the springlocks in the animatronic can be twisted into a suit. They brake even when you breath on them. The crying made them snap. Then he was dead. Plus henry kills himself. He created baby and said it was too late to disassemble her. He felt responsible for the deaths of the children. Pirple guy shows no guilt. Only in sister location. Wanting to contact his dead duaghter.

        Loading editor
    • He sounds like a supervillain from a comic. Maybe he tries to take over the world with an army of killer animatronics.

        Loading editor
    • Skaitleen03 wrote:

      Green Creeper wrote: Umm...

      Who's Henry?

      And Fredbear's family diner as well. I think a silver eyes character. Co founder of Freddy Fazbear's pizza in the boom I think

        Loading editor
    • Green Creeper wrote: But the book has a separate universe to the FNAF lore.

      But also has similarities between them both.

        Loading editor
    • Starscream1998 wrote:
      Nah, the novel lead you to believe Henry was also a villain but it's quickly debunked as Charlie remembers the kind of man Henry was. Having said that http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2287447 I do think in the games Henry ends up as Purple Guy and not William Afton.

      Then go somewhere else. Leave please.

        Loading editor
    • BetaRain wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote:
      Nah, the novel lead you to believe Henry was also a villain but it's quickly debunked as Charlie remembers the kind of man Henry was. Having said that http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2287447 I do think in the games Henry ends up as Purple Guy and not William Afton.

      Then go somewhere else. Leave please.

      Why, for having a different viewpoint?

        Loading editor
    • Sort of.

        Loading editor
    • BetaRain wrote: Sort of.

      Too bad, that's not how things work around here. You provide counter evidence when someone offers criticism on a theory not tell them to leave.

        Loading editor
    • Leave.


      I won't deal with this nonsense anymore.

        Loading editor
    • Starscream1998 wrote:

      BetaRain wrote: Sort of.

      Too bad, that's not how things work around here. You provide counter evidence when someone offers criticism on a theory not tell them to leave.

      It's my theory. So, If you don't like it, please leave.

        Loading editor
    • BetaRain wrote: Leave.


      I won't deal with this nonsense anymore.

      This nonsense is called theorising but sure I've got better things to be doing than arguing.

        Loading editor
    • Henry certainly knows who William is in the novel, and works with him even after the closing of Fredbear's Family Diner, and what looks very much like a situation where William deliberately killed/springlocked Henry's son Sammy. The two have to have a very powerful bond to even stand working with each other after something like that.

      Henry designed the Silver Eyes animatronics, but William was the one who crushed humans inside the springsuits. And Freddy's is specifically built to be run by a two-man team.

      Even Charlie admits later in the novel that she has a hard time dismissing the thought that Henry himself might have played a role in the MCI killings. Including abducting Michael/Golden Freddy in person.

        Loading editor
    • Listen. If you don't like my theory, then don't be a part of this discussion. And also, this is a reboot.

        Loading editor
    • BetaRain wrote:
      Treesicle explained sometime ago that William Afton (The Purple Guy) is actually innocent, and that his friend Henry is the real murderer. I believe that theory, or "true fact" 100%, but I'm not sure if it's even a theory. But here are ten good reason why I believe Henry is the true antagonist of the Five Nights universe:
      1. He is a mastermind and has a big skill on framing.
      2. He created the animatronics in order to frame William for the murders.
      3. I see him as a traitor, corrupting influence, and a Complete Monster.
      4. He can be nicknamed as "The Menace", "The Uncorruptable" or "The Smart One".
      5. I often think of him as a heartless threat to many innocent children.
      6. If he's ever revealed to be an evil mastermind of such potential power, then authorities would not only arrest him, but give him the electric where he will be dead once and for all.
      7. It should have been Henry to be killed by those poor, restless children. Not William.
      8. In my opinion, Fredbear is programmed to be a good-hearted animatronic to every kid. That leads to Henry becoming evil, because his programming plan of making him a killing machine fails.
      9. He's not only a murderous mastermind, but also a very strict gambler who wins a thousand dollars every five nights.
      10. In conclusion, Henry's overall plan is this: Create a diversion to make animatronics as a distraction of William Afton in order to shutdown Fazbear Entertainment after winning 50,000 dollars from a current gamble. Before shutting down the company, he'll kill every kid that goes to the restaurants and stuff them in suits. When he does shut down the company after killing the kids, he'll become the tyrant of Fazbear Entertainment and rule the company all to himself.

      So, what do you fellows believe? Am I making sense, or is this just a big old bag of nonsense?

      Leave your thoughts below.

      To be honest, I think it's nonsense. Remember all the sick and crazy quotes Dave said about the children? Like "They are home with me." or "I'll just walk out of here in the morning, stepping over your corpses." Like he has no problem with seeing dead people? And why would Henry kill his own son and then kill himself over it? Why would he kill all of Charlie's friends? Dave, on the other hand, was even revealed by Clay Burke as William Afton.

        Loading editor
    • You are nonsense.

        Loading editor
    • Did you just expect no one to disagree with or criticize your theory?

      If people think your theory makes no sense, they can have that opinion

      "Only people who agree with the theory can comment" is not how the theorist board works

      People are offering their opinion on why your theory may be wrong

      If you don't want negative criticism or opinions, why did you post your theory for anyone to view and criticize?

      You are going to get disagreement, counter-arguments and opinions wether you like it or not

      And insults like "you are nonsense"? You are insulting someone for disagreeing?

        Loading editor
    • DB511611 wrote:
      Did you just expect no one to disagree with or criticize your theory?

      If people think your theory makes no sense, they can have that opinion

      "Only people who agree with the theory can comment" is not how the theorist board works

      People are offering their opinion on why your theory may be wrong

      If you don't want negative criticism or opinions, why did you post your theory for anyone to view and criticize?

      You are going to get disagreement, counter-arguments and opinions wether you like it or not

      And insults like "you are nonsense"? You are insulting someone for disagreeing?

      No. Not now, not ever.

        Loading editor
    • So, as far as I can gather from this, you're the type of person who thinks they're right, nobody else is.

      When I made my shitty theories and people disagreed with them, I didn't fight them when they were actually critiquing it. But that's what you're doing.

      Starscream had said absolutely nothing bad about your theory. Did he say it was maybe wrong? Sure. Was it in a very rude way?

      "Nah, the novel lead you to believe Henry was also a villain but it's quickly debunked as Charlie remembers the kind of man Henry was. Having said that http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2287447 I do think in the games Henry ends up as Purple Guy and not William Afton."

      That doesn't look like anything rude or very disrespectful. Casual, maybe. But not rude at all.​ And yet, you still tell him:

      "Then go somewhere else. Leave please." Which isn't the way to go about that at all.

      And you even called it nonsense.


      ​TL;DR: You were incredibly rude, and probably owe an apology to at least one person or more.

        Loading editor
    • I meant no disrespect, believe me. But I don't think this is logical. Henry is shown as being a nice, laughing and happy guy, who is only able to fall into depression when one of his own or his childrens' own are killed. I can't really picture him as a sadistic psychopath.

        Loading editor
    • Getting Theorists to agree on.. basically anything is a bit like herding cats. Everyone wants to talk, but few are willing to listen.

      I've been there myself, I'm hardly one to talk. Just keep in mind that solving one of the most amazing mysteries in memory is going to take some teamwork.

      I've already been proven wrong more times than I can count.

        Loading editor
    • I think this guys either a troll or way too young to be on his wikia.

        Loading editor
    • AnnoyingDude wrote: I think this guys either a troll or way too young to be on his wikia.

      Probably both

        Loading editor
    • Darlaimernr wrote: I meant no disrespect, believe me. But I don't think this is logical. Henry is shown as being a nice, laughing and happy guy, who is only able to fall into depression when one of his own or his childrens' own are killed. I can't really picture him as a sadistic psychopath.

      Well PURPLE actually fits Henry more than it does to Afton in terms of color definition.

      Besides, the Sprite killing children in fnaf2 was colored in magenta, giving it a pinkish appearance.

        Loading editor
    • Henry of the novel is innocent but the same may not be able to be said for the Henry of the games.

        Loading editor
    • Starscream1998 wrote:
      Henry of the novel is innocent but the same may not be able to be said for the Henry of the games.

      I don't think there's a change. Still, all the evidence points to Afton being the killer, not Henry.

        Loading editor
    • Darlaimernr wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote:
      Henry of the novel is innocent but the same may not be able to be said for the Henry of the games.

      I don't think there's a change. Still, all the evidence points to Afton being the killer, not Henry.

      FNAF 4 gave me the distinct impression Purple Guy was a father and a technician. If memory serves correctly that sounds more like Henry than William but maybe it's just silly old me.

        Loading editor
    • Jillips Entertainment
      Jillips Entertainment removed this reply because:
      Advertisement
      17:48, October 31, 2016
      This reply has been removed
    • TheLyricArchive wrote: i believe your theory read my theory but when i wrote it i didnt have a name for purple guy only who he was

      http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2320722

      Why do you keep advertising your theory everywhere

        Loading editor
    • DB511611 wrote:

      TheLyricArchive wrote: i believe your theory read my theory but when i wrote it i didnt have a name for purple guy only who he was

      http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2320722

      Why do you keep advertising your theory everywhere

      To be fair I'd be doing that too if I didn't have some solid friends on this board as my threads always fade away into obscurity before 10 comments...that don't go off topic so I can sympathise with this dude a little.

        Loading editor
    • DB511611 wrote:

      TheLyricArchive wrote: i believe your theory read my theory but when i wrote it i didnt have a name for purple guy only who he was

      http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2320722

      Why do you keep advertising your theory everywhere

      Well, I think most people do that to some degree.

      I mean, I do that.

      See? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=86D3qtUlvoI

        Loading editor
    • BlackfootFerret wrote:
      DB511611 wrote:

      TheLyricArchive wrote: i believe your theory read my theory but when i wrote it i didnt have a name for purple guy only who he was

      http://freddy-fazbears-pizza.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:2320722

      Why do you keep advertising your theory everywhere
      Well, I think most people do that to some degree.

      I mean, I do that.

      See? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=86D3qtUlvoI

      If the place didn't need customers it'd get shut down much quicker.

        Loading editor
    • Hmm, it makes since

        Loading editor
    • Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.

        Loading editor
    • Starscream1998 wrote:
      Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.

      Oh no, he exists in the games, but he has no... *enhale* value to the story.

        Loading editor
    • Darlaimernr wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote:
      Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.

      Oh no, he exists in the games, but he has no... *enhale* value to the story.

      Same thing kind of.

        Loading editor
    • Starscream1998 wrote:

      Darlaimernr wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote:
      Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.
      Oh no, he exists in the games, but he has no... *enhale* value to the story.
      Same thing kind of.

      Eh kinda.

        Loading editor
    • Darlaimernr wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote:

      Darlaimernr wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote:
      Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.
      Oh no, he exists in the games, but he has no... *enhale* value to the story.
      Same thing kind of.

      Eh kinda.

      Either ways if I see one more post that attempts to merge the Novel and Game story I think I may need some time away from this board just so I don't explode.

        Loading editor
    • Starscream1998 wrote: Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.

      Henry does exist in the games via Pizzeria Simulator as Cassette Man.

        Loading editor
    • FAZBEARENT9 wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote: Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.

      Henry does exist in the games via Pizzeria Simulator as Cassette Man.

      Would you like to know how much I hate the two of you?

        Loading editor
    • FAZBEARENT9 wrote:

      Starscream1998 wrote: Ok forget my previous comments not only is Henry not guilty he doesn't even exist in the games.

      Henry does exist in the games via Pizzeria Simulator as Cassette Man.

      Dude, that comment was back in 2016, BEFORE we even knew Henry actually existed in the game universe. How were we supposed to know of Henry's existence before this game even came out?

        Loading editor
    • Let's not carry this on, capisce?

        Loading editor
    • games and book are same universe confirmed?

        Loading editor
    • I wouldn't say so.

      At least, not yet.

        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.